top of page
Welcome
Welcome to Costello's Neighborhood Pizza. Our thin and cripsy pizza has been perfected over many years and is sure to satisfy any pizza lover. From our amazing sauce to premium Grande mozzarella cheese, we use only the highest quality ingredients in everything we make.
We look forward to serving you!
Kenny
Matthew T.
"Easily the best pizza on any barrier island. I live on Longboat Key year round, and Costello's is the only spot we use for pizza. When family and friends come in town they are always blown away by the incredible pizza."
Larry W.
"Costello's is absolutely worth the drive. I make the trip from Ruskin area to Longboat Key at least once a week just to treat myself to their pizza. The thin crust is hands down my favorite: perfectly crispy, with a well balanced sauce and just the right combination of toppings.
Tammy R.
"Hands down the best pizza I have had in Florida! Thin crispy great sauce just the right amount of cheese and the dough is spectacular.
Come see what all the hype is about!
Neighborhood Pizza...Gourmet Standards
Pizza by the slice - 2 Slices + Drink only $10.00
Costello's Neighborhood Pizza - Longboat Key
5610 Gulf of Mexico Drive #4
Longboat Key FL 34228
941-383-5551
Monday - Saturday 10:30AM - 10:00PM
Sunday - 12:00PM - 10:00PM
bottom of page